Home Trading Cards & Memorabilia Forum

Confused on how Quick Opinion Service works

I'm a bit confused on how the Quick Opinion service works. The PSA page on this says it will give a opinion on a item that you are interested in purchasing in a auction. The Mantle ball below had a

quick opinion done on it to help sell it in a ebay auction. If that were the case it seems like this would be the way to go because QO is only $10 compared to the $100 it normally costs to

authenticate a Mantle ball. Can someone explain this to me? Thanks. Doug




Quick Opinion Used to sell Mantle Ball

Comments

  • fkwfkw Posts: 1,766 ✭✭
    Quick Opinion is just that..... a Quick Opinion by a person who works for PSA/DNA who looks at a picture of the item and makes a "quick" educated opinion.

    Its not the same as having a COA/LOA from them. If the item comes back from QO as "Likely Genuine" there is a good chance it will pass, but its not guaranteed.

    They would need to see it in person and take a better look before they will give you the better COA/LOA

    PS it is a great way to sell a lower to mid priced raw autographed item on eBay, I have told many people to use it for their items without COA/LOA's. Or at least ad a link to the Quick Opinion so the bidders can check on their own.

    With the excessive fee rate they charge (ie $75 for a DiMaggio item), Sometimes its not worth it for the seller to get an item pre-authenticated by PSA/DNA (w/COA/LOA) before they sell, sometimes the fee is half the TRUE value on some stuff if not more.

    Ruth, Cobb, Gehrig, Waddell, Plank, Wagner.......... yes
    Living/Modern Players, & DiMaggio, Mantle, etc. the fee is usually way too much IMO


  • Thank you fkw. Appreciate the help.
Sign In or Register to comment.