Review Question

corvette1340 · February 21, 2010 11:35AM

If you have a card that has a qualifier, can you send it in for review with a specification for a certain minimum grade with no qualifier?

Example: If I send in a PSA 9(oc), but would rather have it in a PSA 7 NQ holder, will PSA review it that way?

toothshucker · February 21, 2010 11:38AM

EXCELLENT QUESTION. NOT SURE BUT I THINK YOU CAN REQUEST GRADING WITHOUT QUALIFIERS. MAYBE J ORLANDO CAN COMMENT.

otwcards · February 21, 2010 11:47AM

<< <i>If you have a card that has a qualifier, can you send it in for review with a specification for a certain minimum grade with no qualifier?

Example: If I send in a PSA 9(oc), but would rather have it in a PSA 7 NQ holder, will PSA review it that way? >>

Yes, and while a PSA 9 (OC) counts as a PSA 7 for Registry purposes, there's no assurance that it will grade a straight PSA 7...

corvette1340 · February 21, 2010 11:58AM

This scenario could be vice-versa also. I had a PSA 7 '69 Mantle that had razor sharp corners and was brilliant all around except the centering was atrocious. I assume whomever sent it in asked for NQ. The question here would be: If I sent that card in for review, could I request a 9(oc) as minimum grade in the review process?

otwcards · February 21, 2010 12:33PM

<< <i>This scenario could be vice-versa also. I had a PSA 7 '69 Mantle that had razor sharp corners and was brilliant all around except the centering was atrocious. If I sent that card in for review, could I request a 9(oc) as minimum grade in the review process? >>

Absolutely...

Review Question

Comments