Good deal or not t205/206 lot?

I was offered the following cards in a lot today:
T205's: PSA 3 Mathewson, PSA 2 Chance, PSA 2 Bender
T206's: Mathewson Dark Cap Piedmont back and Tinker Bat on shoulder Polar Bear back (both authentic)
He is asking $1000, what do you think? I am meeting him tomorrow to take a look. Any thoughts would be helpful as I have never purchased any cards from these sets.
T205's: PSA 3 Mathewson, PSA 2 Chance, PSA 2 Bender
T206's: Mathewson Dark Cap Piedmont back and Tinker Bat on shoulder Polar Bear back (both authentic)
He is asking $1000, what do you think? I am meeting him tomorrow to take a look. Any thoughts would be helpful as I have never purchased any cards from these sets.
0
Comments
In comparison, I paid $1,358 for all five of those cards, all in PSA 4 shape.
Seems to me that you should be able to get all of them in PSA 2/3 shape, for $700-$800.
Steve
T205 Mathewson PSA 3: $420
T205 Chance PSA 2: $60
T205 Bender PSA 2: $50
T206 Mathewson PSA 2: $250 PSA 3: $320
T206 Tinker PSA 2: $90 PSA 3: $120
Total: $870-$970
"Common sense is the best distributed commodity in the world, for every man is convinced that he is well supplied with it"
For Sale