Options
Does this card look trimmed?
daneyb
Posts: 75
I have been trying for a while to add a Rose rc to my collection that I could afford. I just won one on ebay that was just that. I am comparing it to some of the others on there and now I am concerned it is trimmed. Anyone with a good eye take a look and see what you think.
Click here
Click here
0
Comments
the fact it says 100% authentic and not authentic and unaltered is a red flag
Donato's Complete US Type Set ---- Donato's Dansco 7070 Modified Type Set ---- Donato's Basic U.S. Coin Design Set
Successful transactions: Shrub68 (Jim), MWallace (Mike)
good luck, it IS a pretty card.
Also, notice the seller states it is guaranteed authentic? That is a dead giveaway.
IMO you should buy only a PSA or SGC graded card.
If the card was so good why didn't the seller have it in a holder?
Steve
"Common sense is the best distributed commodity in the world, for every man is convinced that he is well supplied with it"
<< <i>Yes it appears the right side has been hacked.
Also, notice the seller states it is guaranteed authentic? That is a dead giveaway.
IMO you should buy only a PSA or SGC graded card.
If the card was so good why didn't the seller have it in a holder?
Steve >>
In all my raw sports card auctions I always say
Blank card "is guaranteed authentic and 100% unaltered"
Do you think that's bad (hurts my sale price) or as you say is
A dead give away?
The average sale for a PSA 5 is 357.25 psa 6 is 500.00.
So maybe the seller was pretty smart selling it as a raw card figuring it would bring more than a slabbed PSA 6.
I don't see the card even if the back is fine getting a grade higher than PSA 7OC = PSA 5.
If you wanted a raw card for a raw set it is a nice card, but if you wanted to sub it to PSA I think you spent a little to much. JMHO
Plus it is a card that graded brings more then 595.
one last comment, this seller recently sold a PSA graded Ryan rookie so he is well aware
of grading cards.
Steve
PoppaJ
However by stating it is unaltered what would you do if 30 days after a sale a buyer claims it
came back from PSA as altered?
Better to say nothing IMO.
<< <i>It has hardly NO right border.
Plus it is a card that graded brings more then 595.
one last comment, this seller recently sold a PSA graded Ryan rookie so he is well aware
of grading cards.
Steve >>
The 63 rose has more of a border than this PSA 8 oc mick
The card (Rose) would have to grade PSA 7 or higher to bring more than 595 at least according to VCP.
I sell PSA and Raw cards. does this mean because I sell a raw 60 Clemente/whoever that it is altered/trimmed? Some cards bring more raw than slabbed wish I would have cracked out my 54 Kaline Rc (PSA 2) and sold it raw, it brought 81.00 on Feebay.
Although I personally would not sell a raw 52 Mantle , 63 Rose, 86 Jordan, or 79 OPC Gretzky ( because of so many counterfeits) , another person might, my luck Ebay would pull it. If the seller of the Rose left any money on the table , I don't believe it was much if any.
My guess is if it was submitted by the seller it came back; min size reg or MC.
PS: I would be more concerned that the 63 Rose was authentic than trimmed. JMHO