Legit Auction?

Allen · July 19, 2007 5:50PM

Is this Legit?

Cards llok legit, with exception of possibly the Mays. Low feedback seller though. What do you guys think?

jmbkb4 · July 19, 2007 6:04PM

the 3 graded cards seems good to me.

obviously the mays is fake, which casts suspicion on the other cards. why would it not be graded otherwise? why would a seller include the raw card? that bothers me.

JohnnyD · July 19, 2007 10:54PM

Yeah, I do not get a "warm fuzzy feeling" looking at that auction. Something doesn't feel right, not just the Mays, the Mantle bothers me for some reason also.

jimq112 · July 20, 2007 1:35AM

That seller is a consignment seller and probably doesn't know any better.

"The MARION CONNECTION provides our customers the chance to buy and sell on Ebay without having previous ebay experience,a credit card or internet connection.We take the pictures, fill out their information and ship their product." link

Allen · July 20, 2007 4:43AM

I really like that Mantle. I realized they are consignment. I emailed them about the Mays and they said they gurantee it to be 100% authentic and 100% unaltered. I seriously doubt I will bid here, but I sure would like to buy that lot at a steal and move the payton and magic and cut my money on the Mantle, the mays I would likely trash.

CDsNuts · July 20, 2007 5:03AM

Mantle is worth about a grand, maybe a little more. The Mays, if legit, would be worth about $300 and the Bird/Magic and Payton are $150 cards. Factor in the probability that the Mays is fake and the lot is worth about $1500 (and about $1700 if the Mays is legit). I don't see this one going for under $1200, so there's no way you're stealing anything here.

Allen · July 20, 2007 5:20AM

I know its not a steal, but I really like the Mantle eye appeal as most low grade on eBay are unpresentable.

Legit Auction?

Comments