Home Buy, Sell & Trade - Cards & Memorabilia
Options

anyone resubmit cards after receiving 'altered'?

Hi guys,

I feel like a radio caller, but first time poster, long time reader.

Anyways, I wanted to see if anyone else has had experiences like this. I submitted a T-206 Miller Huggins (hands at mouth) to PSA about 6 months ago, and got it back as being "recolored". I looked at the card 100 times under every light, etc., and it didn't seem to have anything wrong with it. I re-submitted it and just got it back graded as a 5, which is about what I was hoping for. Is this a common experience?

I also have a common T-206 which I thought should grade about a 7, that was returned to me as "trimmed" but has matched up perfectly to every other T-206 I have in size, etc. Have other people been through this as well? Have people been successful in getting things graded the second time around?

Comments

  • Options
    What do you have to lose?

    ......if it comes back Trimmed - then you're no worse off!!!
  • Options
    I've had that happen to me. I sent in three t206s that were bought from a gentleman who had owned them since he was a young man. there were all extremely high grade. The Chase white hat came back an eight, the Tinker and Chase blue portrait came back as trimmed. The Tinker was sent to Sgc and was graded and the Chase blue portrait was resubmitted to psa and came back as trimmed again. If it is trimmed, I can't tell. It is the correct size, it just looks pristine to me. Maybe, I will send it in to sgc also, but I would surely like to have it in my psa registry!
Sign In or Register to comment.