Home Trading Cards & Memorabilia Forum

Will Thurman Munson ever be elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame?

Inquiring Larry's want to know! image
WANTED: Cincinnati Reds TEAM Cards

Comments

  • jackstrawjackstraw Posts: 3,819 ✭✭✭✭
    I think he should.
    Collector Focus

    ON ITS WAY TO NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92658
  • IronmanfanIronmanfan Posts: 5,525 ✭✭✭✭
    Hall of Decent

    IMF
    Successful dealings with Wcsportscards94558, EagleEyeKid, SamsGirl214, Volver, DwayneDrain, Oaksey25, Griffins, Cardfan07, Etc.
  • Stone193Stone193 Posts: 24,486 ✭✭✭✭✭
    ROY, 1976 AL MVP, 7 AS games (10 full years), 3 Gold Gloves, really good post-season performance, 2 WS rings (3 appearances)

    Not bad - but does his overall "stats" match up to other catcher HOF'ers?

    Mike
  • lostdart58lostdart58 Posts: 2,938 ✭✭✭
    Hall of Lousy Signer.
    Collector of:Baseball
    1955 Bowman Raw complete with 90% Ex-NR or better

    Now seeking 1949 Eureka Sportstamps...NM condition
    Working on '78 Autographed set now 99.9% complete -
    Working on '89 Topps autoed set now complete


  • Should be but won't because he was a Yankee and didn't have enough productive years (just anticipating the comments we will get here)
    But like mattingly his number is hanging up where it counts.
  • larryallen73larryallen73 Posts: 6,069 ✭✭✭
    He should be. Not his fault he died. My recollection is he was still at the top of his game when he died.
  • dtkk49adtkk49a Posts: 2,490 ✭✭✭
    If he deserves to be in, so do a lot of other players. He was the Yankee captain, but I don't know if that was enough to keep him as a Yankee once his contract expired. We will never know if he would have signed with Cleveland once his contract with the Yankees ended. He was not a Steinbrenner fan to say the least. He hated Reggie and he hated New York. That's why he was learning how to fly - so that he could fly back to Ohio when he wasn't playing.

    That being said, he is still one of my favorite players and I have a bunch of his cards, including a bunch of PSA graded 71's
    Follow me - Cards_and_Coins on Instagram



    They call me "Pack the Ripper"
  • VitoCo1972VitoCo1972 Posts: 6,135 ✭✭✭
    His case gets worse every year. Sabermetrics would tell you that a .756 career OPS out of a power position isn't HOF worthy. Even his MVP year is (using modern stats) one of the weakest ever. George Brett led the league in hits, total bases, triples and batting average that year and his OPS was 80 points higher on a team that won it's division. I would argue that Munson wouldn't have won the award if he didn't play in NYC.
  • Hank36Hank36 Posts: 175 ✭✭


    << <i>He should be. Not his fault he died. My recollection is he was still at the top of his game when he died. >>


    I'm not so sure about that--he was 32, his offense had fallen off the year before, his knees were in pretty bad shape, and many agree that he wanted to be traded to Cleveland.

    The thing with Munson is that he was worshipped by his teammates and detested by the media, which was likely a major factor in his not getting voted in during his initial period of eligibility. I certainly think he deserves to be in Cooperstown, although much of what made him great are the intagible things that don't show up in a line of stats.
  • He never received more than 16% of the HOF vote in any of his 15 years on the ballot. No way he ever gets in.

    He's Bill Freehan in pinstripes.
  • gemintgemint Posts: 6,178 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>He never received more than 16% of the HOF vote in any of his 15 years on the ballot. No way he ever gets in.

    He's Bill Freehan in pinstripes. >>



    I agree with this, though slightly better than Freehan. He likely was past his prime when he died. Had he played out the string, he may have had 4-5 more seasons with mediocre production. That resume probably would not get him in. The only thing he has going for him is his position which traditionally hasn't been stacked with great hitters.


  • << <i>He should be. Not his fault he died. My recollection is he was still at the top of his game when he died. >>



    His slugging percentage and extra-base hits fell but a huge amount after he turned 30, his strikeout rate increased significantly. Hard to see that reversing as he continued to age

    Joe Torre was far better and more deserving even without his success as a manager. Ted Simmons was definitely better. Bill Freehan is a good comparison, but the Tigers catcher ended up with a better career
  • orioles93orioles93 Posts: 3,491 ✭✭✭✭✭
    very good, but not good enough for the hall.
    What I Collect:

    PSA HOF Baseball Postwar Rookies Set Registry- (Currently 80.51% Complete)


    PSA Pro Football HOF Rookie Players Set Registry- (Currently 19.80% Complete)


    PSA Basketball HOF Players Rookies Set Registry- (Currently 6.02% Complete)
  • royalbrettroyalbrett Posts: 620 ✭✭✭


    << <i>His case gets worse every year. Sabermetrics would tell you that a .756 career OPS out of a power position isn't HOF worthy. Even his MVP year is (using modern stats) one of the weakest ever. George Brett led the league in hits, total bases, triples and batting average that year and his OPS was 80 points higher on a team that won it's division. I would argue that Munson wouldn't have won the award if he didn't play in NYC. >>



    It has finally been recognized. Brett should have won at least two MVP awards. One could make the case for '76, '79, and for sure 1985.
    Yeah, I uploaded that KC icon in 2001
  • EstilEstil Posts: 7,226 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>Should be but won't because he was a Yankee and didn't have enough productive years (just anticipating the comments we will get here)
    But like mattingly his number is hanging up where it counts. >>



    As I've said before, Mattingly was literally one year short. Just one more year and he'd have his championship (not to mention the 1994 strike missing him a probable second title). Then he would've had no trouble getting into Cooperstown.
    WISHLIST
    D's: 50P,49S,45D+S,43D,41S,40D,39D+S,38D+S,37D+S,36S,35D+S,all 16-34's
    Q's: 52S,47S,46S,40S,39S,38S,37D+S,36D+S,35D,34D,32D+S
    74T: 241,435,610,654 97 Finest silver: 115,135,139,145,310
    73T:31,55,61,62,63,64,65,66,67,68,80,152,165,189,213,235,237,257,341,344,377,379,390,422,433,453,480,497,545,554,563,580,606,613,630
    95 Ultra GM Sets: Golden Prospects,HR Kings,On-Base Leaders,Power Plus,RBI Kings
  • pclpadspclpads Posts: 457 ✭✭


    << <i>He never received more than 16% of the HOF vote in any of his 15 years on the ballot. No way he ever gets in.

    He's Bill Freehan in pinstripes. >>



    +1 Being Yankee Capt. got Rizzuto in so there is always an outside chance. But if he played in Milwaukee or KC, we wouldn't be having this discussion.
  • jeffcbayjeffcbay Posts: 8,951 ✭✭✭✭


    << <i>He should be. Not his fault he died. My recollection is he was still at the top of his game when he died. >>



    Fun fact, I drive right past the spot where his plane crashed every day to and from work. Yay.
  • dennis07dennis07 Posts: 1,842 ✭✭✭
    "Not his fault he died."

    Unfortunately that statement is debatable


    Thurman L. Munson, Cessna Citation 501, N15NY
    Canton, Ohio
    August 2, 1979

    NTSB Number: AAR-80-02


    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Executive Summary
    About 1602 e.d.t., on August 2, 1979, a Cessna Citation piloted by Mr.Thurman L. Munson crashed short of runway 19 at the Akron-Canton Airport near Canton, Ohio. The pilot was practicing touch-and-go landings during a local flight with two passengers aboard. The aircraft first touched down in a relatively level, clear area about 870 f t short of the runway. The aircraft slid through a small clump of trees, hit a large stump, and came to rest on a road adjacent to the airport boundary fence. Fire erupted immediately after the aircraft came to rest. The two passengers escaped from the wreckage; the pilot was killed.

    Probable Cause
    The National Transportation Safety Board determines that the probable cause of the accident was the pilot's failure to recognize the need for, and to take action to maintain, sufficient airspeed to prevent a stall into the ground during an attempted landing. The pilot also failed to recognize the need for timely and sufficient power application to prevent the stall during an approach conducted inadvertently without flaps extended. Contributing to the pilot's inability to recognize the problem and to take proper action was his failure to use the appropriate checklist and his nonstandard pattern procedures which resulted in an abnormal approach profile.
    Collecting 1970 Topps baseball
  • shagrotn77shagrotn77 Posts: 5,628 ✭✭✭✭
    You could make a strong case either way. That he's gained so little attention from the voters, though, leads me to believe that he'll never get in.
    "My father would womanize, he would drink. He would make outrageous claims like he invented the question mark. Sometimes he would accuse chestnuts of being lazy. The sort of general malaise that only the genius possess and the insane lament. Our childhood was typical. Summers in Rangoon, luge lessons. In the spring we'd make meat helmets. When we were insolent we were placed in a burlap bag and beaten with reeds - pretty standard really."
  • jeffcbayjeffcbay Posts: 8,951 ✭✭✭✭


    << <i>"Not his fault he died."

    Unfortunately that statement is debatable


    Thurman L. Munson, Cessna Citation 501, N15NY
    Canton, Ohio
    August 2, 1979

    NTSB Number: AAR-80-02


    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Executive Summary
    About 1602 e.d.t., on August 2, 1979, a Cessna Citation piloted by Mr.Thurman L. Munson crashed short of runway 19 at the Akron-Canton Airport near Canton, Ohio. The pilot was practicing touch-and-go landings during a local flight with two passengers aboard. The aircraft first touched down in a relatively level, clear area about 870 f t short of the runway. The aircraft slid through a small clump of trees, hit a large stump, and came to rest on a road adjacent to the airport boundary fence. Fire erupted immediately after the aircraft came to rest. The two passengers escaped from the wreckage; the pilot was killed.

    Probable Cause
    The National Transportation Safety Board determines that the probable cause of the accident was the pilot's failure to recognize the need for, and to take action to maintain, sufficient airspeed to prevent a stall into the ground during an attempted landing. The pilot also failed to recognize the need for timely and sufficient power application to prevent the stall during an approach conducted inadvertently without flaps extended. Contributing to the pilot's inability to recognize the problem and to take proper action was his failure to use the appropriate checklist and his nonstandard pattern procedures which resulted in an abnormal approach profile. >>



    When the plane came to rest on the two-lane roadway (Greensburg Road), Munson was conscious and even asked the other two guys if they were okay. Munson's legs were pinned, and his neck was broken. The guys tried to get him out but the plane was filling with thick black smoke and they had to exit the plane. The plane became fully engulfed and he was killed by the fire. Sad story. One of his sons still lives around here and even owned a bar in town for a while (called Munson's) but it closed a few years ago.


  • << <i> Munson was conscious and even asked the other two guys if they were okay. >>




    That's the reason he's my favorite all time ball player. And one of the reasons I feel he should be in the Hall Of Fame also.

    Anyone who's burning to death and his only concern is for his friends gets my vote for greatest guy ever.

    RIP Thurman. image
  • jeffcbayjeffcbay Posts: 8,951 ✭✭✭✭


    << <i>

    << <i> Munson was conscious and even asked the other two guys if they were okay. >>




    That's the reason he's my favorite all time ball player. And one of the reasons I feel he should be in the Hall Of Fame also.

    Anyone who's burning to death and his only concern is for his friends gets my vote for greatest guy ever.

    RIP Thurman. image >>



    True dat... here is a video about it: Youtubes
  • jackstrawjackstraw Posts: 3,819 ✭✭✭✭
    I loved Munson and I can remember the exact spot I was when I heard the news.
    That being said I heard he was a little harsh or a lot harsh to others? Someone
    told a story about an autograph hunt year in and year out and Munson would never sign
    for the kid and one year as he was getting on the bus the kid ran up and as Munson looked at
    him he snorted a huge loogy and spat at his feet.........
    Collector Focus

    ON ITS WAY TO NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92658
  • fkwfkw Posts: 1,766 ✭✭
    NO!
Sign In or Register to comment.