Let's play the game of Guess The Grade....

Dpeck100

I recently got these cards back from PSA in the past month.

Please take a moment and assess the cards and give what your pre screening grade would be.

I am curious what others initial thoughts are on these cards. There is no corner damage on the reverse or any other issues.

bobbybakeriv

9, 8, 8? I'm not at all familiar with wrestling cards though.

handyman

7,8,8

HAMMERFAN44

8
8
Auth

ThoseBackPages

8,7,6

Dpeck100

This is great so far. A wide variety of grades. I want to see a few more and then the reveal.

Boopotts

7,8,7, assuming that's snow on the third one.

Bosox1976

6,7,8

PaulMaul

7,8,7

Dpeck100

This was fun. Some of the boards better card graders chimed in and I appreciate the participation.

I am baffled at times when I see cards with heavily damaged corners and hopes for high grades. All four of these cards have mint corners and that is why I started this thread.

The first card graded a PSA 7. I am assuming the top to bottom centering was the primary issue most had with the card.

The second card graded a PSA 7. There is obvious snow on the card and the centering is strong with it just being a touch off on the left side.

The third card graded a PSA 6. Once again the top to bottom centering is a touch off and the white specs in the scan are not on the card.

What is interesting is the wide range of grades. This proves that grading is subjective to some degree with little consensus across the board.

Dboneesq

And the winner is ERIC (TBP) ... off by 1 grade on the first one and called the last two correctly!

dennis07

I'm not an expert by far especially with wrestling cards but my grades were 8 (OC), 7, 8 (OC). I promise I didn't cheat