Bill James' (Hypothetical) HOF Ballot

markj111

From billjamesonline.com Much of the site is free.


I believe he would vote for Bagwell as well.


Hey Bill, what would your 2012 HOF ballot looked like?
Asked by: Steve9753

Answered: 1/15/2013

Raines, Rocket, Biggio, Piazza, Edgar Martinez, Trammell, McGriff, McGwire. Maybe another one or two. ..I dunno

markj111

Apparently your opinion is different from his.

perkdog

Makes zero sense to me to leave Bonds off that list

fiveniner

I do not believe in all this sybermatric junk.

NVbaseball

Only one I couldn't support is Martinez. Larry Walker was nearly as good a hitter -- even in Montreal -- and a top defensive player. I'm on the fence on Trammell. Best shortstop not yet in (far better than Vizquel), but hard to vote for him when Whitaker wasn't close