$195 coin? Or why I don't get hired as a grader...

pharmer

Bought this raw as ms-64, and when I got it knew it was not that, but NGC au58 bummed me out. The seller has offered to buy it back for $195. Now all of a sudden I like it again. Should I sell it or keep it? I do like the look, one of the prettier SLQ's I've seen. Opinions?

kryptonitecomics

It's quite attractive...not know what's its actual value is via grey sheet.....I still like it and would think about keeping it if I were you. Now if $195 is MS64 money...then I might have to consider the offer. The dealer could be making out either way as now the coin is certified.

LeeG

That is a very attractive SLQ. I've been searching for one similar to that myself. Seems like a good price to me. But only you can be the judge of that Lee

etexmike

I love the tone on that SLQ.

I can understand you being bummed about the grade.

I think I would keep it. But it is your money.

-----------

etexmike

Smittys

Price seems a little HIGH, it is pretty but 95.00 extra pretty???
JMHO

XpipedreamR

I think it's got a great look, and I would keep it. It's definitely worth a premium over a run-of-the mill AU58. It's not like you're taking an ENORMOUS hit on the coin, I don't think.

airplanenut

It sure is pretty, and you rarely see nice color on an SLQ... it really depends on what you paid, and what you can afford.

Jeremy

Coinhusker1

MS-60 ask is around $100, so I'd probably "put" it back to the dealer for the $195. Then you can buy a real MS-63/4 or two AU-58s!!

DNADave

It's always a good idea to keep "lessons learned" coins if you can afford to. It will help to keep that from happening again.

CHESSNUTDOG

PM sent

EvilMCT

<< <i>It's always a good idea to keep "lessons learned" coins if you can afford to. It will help to keep that from happening again. >>




Ken

nwcs

Myself, I would send it back.

Merc

Neat rim toning. Looks like it had been in a carboard album or possible a paper coin wrapper. I agree with the AU58.

blueifalcon

I'll take it!

OK, now back to reality.. I'm pretty new at this coin collecting game, but I won't buy a coin if I don't like it. Once I buy, I keep...Lesson learned, enjoy the beauty...P.S. Don't smack me around too much, OTAY?