An undergraded coin on e-bay

mbbiker

I just bid on this auction, the seller says AG i think its Fine or better what do you think?

e-bay

prooflike

I think the rim is worn down at 11 o'clock.

zenny

not bad looking for ag.

nwcs

Hmm, I wonder who it is since they are here in the same city...

beelzebud

Obverse shows "we" , so unless there is some sort of planchet problem (image is not the greatest) then I would grade the obverse fine - reverse looks weaker.
JMO.


Bill

Russ

To me, the the obverse looks VF+, and the reverse G. But, the toning on it looks splotchy and suspicious. Frankly, it doesn't even look like the same coin comparing the two sides - unless the reverse was very weakly struck.

mbbiker,

In any event, my opinion is that you're right. It grades better than AG. I may have to snipe it.

Russ, NCNE

mbbiker

russ, if you want it go for it.