SCD Crossover Experiment

mintyfresh · August 14, 2005 2:33PM

I think we should get a couple of folks to pick up some cheap SCD cards and cross them over to PSA, SGC, or BGS. This will answer whether this is just another chop shop, or if they are legit, do they inflate their grades. I'll pick up 3 and let you guys know the results.

zef204 · August 14, 2005 2:39PM

I already did. I picked up a 1976 fb SCD 9 common and it has already been sent in. I was pleasently surprised in its condition. It looked more like a 9 than this 1974 fb SGC 96 common which also has already been submitted.

mintyfresh · August 14, 2005 2:50PM

Sweet, please post the results when you get it back.

bobbybakeriv · August 14, 2005 2:50PM

Sounds like a plan. I just sent in a 1976 Topps SCD 10 Lee Roy Jordan myself. The card looks pretty darned good honestly. We shall see though.

SCD 10

Zef, looking at this one again, I think you were also bidding on it. Cool.

Stingray · August 14, 2005 9:19PM

Just wondering, are you cracking and sending or submitting them in the case?

Stingray

jayhawke · August 14, 2005 11:12PM

I second Stingray's question.

zef204 · August 14, 2005 11:45PM

Crack and send. The only way to go.

studentT206 · August 15, 2005 2:21AM

This should be interesting as this in the "new SCD" and not the company that Krause ran for years which I think was good.

Damian

bobbybakeriv · August 15, 2005 3:50AM

Without question, crack and then submit.

EagleEyeKid · August 15, 2005 4:31AM

I have cracked and resubmitted a SCD 10 (new blue label) 1983 Topps Wade Boggs and received a PSA 9. The card was perfect in every aspect except for the surface which can be seen clearly once it was outside of its holder. It had a ton of those fish eyes (faded) that could be seen if the card was tilted properly. I would say buy the card if you can pick it up cheap. I would not pay more than PSA 9 price if the card is a 10.

bobbybakeriv · August 22, 2005 5:55AM

I just got grade for the 76 Lee Roy Jordan referenced above ....PSA 9. Not too shabby.

zef204 · August 22, 2005 6:29AM

When did you send it in? Mine haven't even entered the system.

bobbybakeriv · August 22, 2005 7:00AM

I sent a 26 card submission in on the 15th. The cards were checked as received on the 17th. I posted the results over on the 72-92 thread on the set registry link.

zef204 · August 23, 2005 1:56PM

<< <i>I already did. I picked up a 1976 fb SCD 9 common and it has already been sent in. I was pleasently surprised in its condition. It looked more like a 9 than this 1974 fb SGC 96 common which also has already been submitted. >>

Grades just popped

1976 scd 9 Randy Vataha now PSA 9
1974 SGC 96(9) Roy Gerela now PSA 8

others that I crossed recently

1959 scd(old flip) 8 Ron Kline now PSA 8

1962 SGC(86(7.5) Sanny Esposito now PSA 8
1970-71 SGC 92(8.5) Dave Newmark now PSA 9
1989 SGC 92(8.5) Ken Griffey now PSA 8

1977 BVG(old flip grades on back) 8.5 Mel Blount now PSA 9

1973 GAI 8.5 Bob Gibson now PSA 9
1984 GAI 8 John Elway now PSA 8
1959 GAI 8 Valmy Thomas now PSA 8
1986 GAI 8 Bonds now PSA 8

To be fair I resubmitted 2 PSA's that I thought were undergraded. I was right.

1984 PSA 7 Steve Young now PSA 8
1984 PSA 8 Don Mattingly now PSA 9

envoy98 · August 23, 2005 1:59PM

Wow, you hit it out of the park Zef. I think you did tremendously well with those.

BTW, when did you send these in and under what service level? Also, I'll assume these were all crack and resubmits based on your previous post?

zef204 · August 29, 2005 2:13AM

Most of them were sent in under this month's and last month's $5 special. And absolutely crack and submit is the only way to go. Say yes to crack!

WinPitcher · August 29, 2005 2:47AM

I agree with Jason.............errr Jordan.

SD

Knuckles · August 29, 2005 3:02AM

Cool, thanks for sharing.

zef204 · August 29, 2005 4:05AM

<< <i>I agree with Jason.............errr Jordan >>

I was also called, zed, zee, zep...

I just saw that he went back and edited all his meesages with my misnomers. I think Greg hit the nail on the head, rbd has too much time on his hands.

rbdjr1 · August 29, 2005 5:39AM

<< <i>

<< <i>I agree with Jason.............errr Jordan >>

I was also called, zed, zee, zep...

I just saw that he went back and edited all his meesages with my misnomers. I think Greg hit the nail on the head, rbd has too much time on his hands. >>

Well jason (just kidding Jordan!). I thought it was the classy thing to do, to spend the time to edit/correct your mis-spelled name and ID. And yes, it did take some time out of my life to do that. But if you like, I'll spend some more time and edit again, back to "jason and zep"? Nah!!!!!!!!!!!!

rbd

carew4me · August 29, 2005 5:47AM

A modern day Sylvester McMonkey McBean.

CDsNuts · August 29, 2005 9:38AM

Anybody know if the new SCD has been known to grade trimmed cards?

Lee

SCD Crossover Experiment

Comments