Search
-
Re: You know, I really sick of hearing how overgraded NGC coins are and how perfect PCGS is...
<< <i>People with knowledge buy the coin not the plastic , one can reasonably deduce based on actual resale prices and auction realised prices that the majority of the time PCGS gets it right and NGC is second fiddle. >> See my example above. Even if you alter my example so that both services got it right at the same rate,… -
Re: You know, I really sick of hearing how overgraded NGC coins are and how perfect PCGS is...
Gawd another NGC vs PCGS arguement, guess what you could crack out 50 coins out of each companies holders and send them in for regrade and less than 75% would come out the same grade. For you modern addicts crack out 30 MS or PF 70's from PCGS holders and resubmit. How many of those 30 would come back as 70's? Half, three… -
You know, I really sick of hearing how overgraded NGC coins are and how perfect PCGS is...
Get a life people, there are crap coins in PCGS and NGC holders. Overgraded coins in both holders and undergraded coins in both. You people who paint the broad streak that NGC coins are always overgraded need to wake up and smell the coffee. If that statement were true, then PCGS wouldn't offer crossover service now would… -
Re: You know, I really sick of hearing how overgraded NGC coins are and how perfect PCGS is...
<< <i> Get a life people, there are crap coins in PCGS and NGC holders. Overgraded coins in both holders and undergraded coins in both. You people who paint the broad streak that NGC coins are always overgraded need to wake up and smell the coffee. If that statement were true, then PCGS wouldn't offer crossover service now… -
Re: You know, I really sick of hearing how overgraded NGC coins are and how perfect PCGS is...
The plastic matters, the plastic matters and the plastic has always mattered. Black and white photos mattered then color photos mattered and they brought more money and they brought more attention way back when (1975). The plastic matters is creates competition it keeps one and the other company in check. The plastic… -
Re: You know, I really sick of hearing how overgraded NGC coins are and how perfect PCGS is...
<< <i>Now this thread can hit 500! There is a problem at ALL grading services. You WILL find OVEGRADED coins in anyones holders. I don't think the fearless leaders of the services will deny that. Both services have their good points and bad points. There are coins I would NEVER buy in a PCGS holder an those I would NEVER… -
Re: You know, I really sick of hearing how overgraded NGC coins are and how perfect PCGS is...
True story...about 3 years ago, I CROSSED an ACG 64 Rainbow toned Morgan into a PCGS 66! Its not even that I thought it was undergraded - I said "cross at any MS grade"! I was hoping for at least an MS-62! Do you have pics of this morgan- I'd love to see them... -
Re: You know, I really sick of hearing how overgraded NGC coins are and how perfect PCGS is...
Mr Pharmer : I have already recieved 2 private messages warning me about you . I have seen many a post casting an unfavorable light on you . You seem to be the kid on the playground that nobody wants to play with . You have stalked me on these boards since my first post I'd like to hear a little more about the stalking... -
Re: You know, I really sick of hearing how overgraded NGC coins are and how perfect PCGS is...
<<Personally, I find it hard to believe that the mint can churn out so FEW "perfect" coins, as PCGS seems to think. They come right off the line, go into a plastic holder and many of them go right to the TPGs... ...I think NGC is more realistic on their modern grading, and PCGS may be making the market and feeding the… -
Re: You know, I really sick of hearing how overgraded NGC coins are and how perfect PCGS is...
ngc is SLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW
119 results