Search
-
Last Submission: I know now the grader who graded these has no clue as to what he is doing:
VARIETY COUNTRY GRADE 1950 50C USA Damage ....this coin was perfect 1951-D 50C USA Cleaning ....reworking of the die what he saw was die polish. 1951 50C USA Damage ....reworking of the die 1952-D 50C USA MS64FL ...under graded 1952 50C USA AU58 ....under graded 1953-D 50C USA MS64FL ...under graded 1954-D 50C USA MS62FL… -
Re: Last Submission: I know now the grader who graded these has no clue as to what he is doing:
dlimb2- how about some pictures of these coins on your last submission that PCGS messed up as well?LINK If you can show pictures of these coins being badly undergraded it would give a lot of clout to your statements. mike -
Re: Last Submission: I know now the grader who graded these has no clue as to what he is doing:
<< <i> << <i>Russ, these are my second...and what does the amount of submissions have to do with the grade of a coin >> It has a lot to do with learning how PCGS grades. When I only had two submissions under my belt, I also thought PCGS had no idea what they were doing. It's all part of the educational curve. Reading a… -
Re: Last Submission: I know now the grader who graded these has no clue as to what he is doing:
<< <i>mcs, I have the Complete Guide to Franklin Half Dollars by Rick omaska...I ahave also compared my Franklins to many graded Franklins...I have also had a couple of people who frequent this board look at these Franklins...besides, I stayed in a Holiday Inn last night...so I did not just sind them in on a whim. >> -
Re: Last Submission: I know now the grader who graded these has no clue as to what he is doing:
dlimb2.. didn't you have the same complaint with your 1st submission? You posted here about those bad results also. -
Re: Last Submission: I know now the grader who graded these has no clue as to what he is doing:
dlimb2, How many submissions have you put through PCGS? Russ, NCNE -
Re: Last Submission: I know now the grader who graded these has no clue as to what he is doing:
How do you know Russ have you seen the coins? No I can tell you, you have not! Were you with me when I compared them to other PCGS graded coins...no you were not! -
Re: Last Submission: I know now the grader who graded these has no clue as to what he is doing:
If you take off the damaged and cleaned you get 1952-D 50C USA MS64FL ...under graded 1952 50C USA AU58 ....under graded 1953-D 50C USA MS64FL ...under graded 1954-D 50C USA MS62FL ....under graded 1963 50C USA MS64 ...under graded Actually MS64 is the average grade, when I saw your coins (I only glanced at them), I didn't… -
Re: Last Submission: I know now the grader who graded these has no clue as to what he is doing:
Well, since you opened the door to the question, (and I'm trying to ask very politely and nicely) how knowledgeable are you regarding franklins? Can you give us some details with which to understand where you are coming from? How long have you collected them? What resources have you read/studied? Can you show us some pics… -
Re: Last Submission: I know now the grader who graded these has no clue as to what he is doing:
<< <i> Post a picture of the whole coin please. >> No kidding! All I see is what appears to be a surface that has been harshly cleaned.
61 results