Search
-
Re: After the passing of Willie May's, who is the greatest living player now?
-
Re: After the passing of Willie May's, who is the greatest living player now?
-
Re: After the passing of Willie May's, who is the greatest living player now?
-
Re: After the passing of Willie May's, who is the greatest living player now?
Pretty sure I started my opinion with a big "If" in there somewhere. Everyone went down the injury route in their 30s with Griffey, Pujols and now Trout. So yes, I will restate, 'IF' Ohtani can go 4 more seasons both pitching and hitting at a high level with the hardware and accolades to boot, he'll be in the conversation… -
Re: After the passing of Willie May's, who is the greatest living player now?
-
Re: After the passing of Willie May's, who is the greatest living player now?
-
Re: After the passing of Willie May's, who is the greatest living player now?
this. I think people get all wound up about the lore and majesty of Koufax. like the Beatles, he retired at his peak powers. there is always very strong nostalgia when that happens. Koufax was GREAT for 3-4 seasons. thats it. I will take Bob Gibson every single time. He had a higher peak and better career value. -
Re: After the passing of Willie May's, who is the greatest living player now?
My main point was that Koufax is being hugely over-rated here as an all time great. That's not really debatable. Aaron and Morgan were commenting on how good Koufax was, not from 1955-1961 when he sucked, but 1963-1966 when he was dominant. Sandy had a great 4 year run, no argument there, although he was injured for one of… -
Re: After the passing of Willie May's, who is the greatest living player now?
> > > You don't have to agree with any facts you don't like. Koufax had 3 great years (although he was just average away from Dodger Stadium during those seasons) and 1 fantastic year. He also had 6 years where he was either not used or ineffective. He had one other year where he was pretty good. These are facts. You can… -
Re: After the passing of Willie May's, who is the greatest living player now?
1) Bonds, 2) Pujols, 3) Clemens, 4) Arod, 5) Maddux, 6) Henderson, 7) Griffey, Jr., 8) Randy Johnson, 9) Ryan, 10) Schmidt. Juice or not, these are the best living players in order. All of their numbers pre-juice even stand up against the all-time greats. Greenies were prolific in the 70s and 80s. PEDs were prolific in the…
12 results