shish ✭✭✭✭✭

IMHO there is no debate that PCGS has been more strict in many series most of the time. However, currently I'm convinced that CACG is now the leader in both strict standards and consistency. (View Post)

"I may not have conveyed my concept clearly. I was suggesting that if a TPG could achieve a 3-5% overall "error" rate they would be doing well." I agree, unfortunately my point is… (View Post)

The following terms are being used very liberally. "Market Grading." is not a well defined standard. "Market Acceptable" is not well defined. Exactly who decides what is market ac… (View Post)

"Except eye appeal is nowhere in their published standards. If it were part of their grading, "I'm sure they would have made the distinction. " I disagree! The published standards need… (View Post)

"While grading is subjective, that would be an express non-subjective violation of the standard that Unc coins must not have any wear. In my world, that would fall under policy change rather tha… (View Post)