-
Re: is this the worst group ever chosen for the HOF?
No. See above, but the VC selections of the early '70s are even worse. O'Neil, like Tommy John, should be in as a builder. Oliva should never have gotten in for what he might have done had … (View Post)1 -
Re: Does Bonds finally get in?
Bonds is the only player who can reasonably be compared to Ruth as the best player of all time. There are far, far worse players with more credible cheating allegations already enshrined. Winning MVP… (View Post)3 -
Re: My oh my how the mighty have fallen
You say this as though there is no value to playing a key defensive position adequately. No one would confuse Trout with Andruw Jones or even Dom Dimaggio, but it's not like he's Ken Griffe… (View Post)1 -
Re: My oh my how the mighty have fallen
As long as you accept that no player, in the history of baseball, cost his team more on defense than Jeter did, and it isn't terribly close. This isn't to say that Jeter was a worse defensi… (View Post)3 -
Re: Big Papi
ESPN had an interesting take. They said he should get in because he wasn't actually that good. Specifically they said that it is easy to excuse the PED usage because unlike Bonds or Clemens he d… (View Post)2