daltex ✭✭✭✭✭

I actually agree with this. Peak Nettles is not much worse than peak Robinson. The problem is that Nettles was able to play at that high defensive level for only seven years while Robinson was able t… (View Post)

Perhaps I don't understand what you mean by 1/17?? (View Post)

Not sure if you're asking me to round out my top 5, but Jimmy Collins, Clete (not Ken) Boyer, and Schmidt have to be in the discussion. By the way, all the metrics correct for the Pitcher vs. DH… (View Post)

Worst player to ever win MVP? Don't misunderstand me, he was absolutely deserving that year, but the rest of his career was remarkably unremarkable. I don't know who the other contenders wo… (View Post)

My interpretation of his point is that with the Brett you know what you have, but if you were to open either box you have no idea if you'll get something better or worse. It's a valid point… (View Post)