Walkerlover ✭✭✭✭

No confusion, I pick coins with super luster and good strikes with no spotting or other issues and top eye appeal as you can see from my previous posts. I want the assurance that the coins pass as so… (View Post)

I was going to let this thread die but while I was looking for CAC Washington Quarters I came across this coin. Dark toned with black ugly spotting. Worse than the other coin I posted even though the… (View Post)

I just expressed an opinion on a coin that is very legitimate and you are downgrading it. Guaranteed if this coin was posted by a member here it would be a soft or hard pass by 95% of collectors. If … (View Post)

Question is how does a coin like this pass CAC with such a dark ugly look. Reinforcing my opinion that luster and eye appeal don’t rate as much as contact marks and original surfaces. (View Post)

Yes it’s only a small factor. There are many unattractive coins in CAC holders as well as many amazing ones (View Post)