StrikeOutXXX ✭✭✭✭✭

Andy did his homework on his page below citing an early auction record: These were often offered in the pattern sections of sales by Cogan, Woodward and Mason & Company who were well aware of the… (View Post)

Tom, Looking at the blown-up PCGS photos - if they lined up the previously struck coin as you suspect, they were spot on. There are a few places that kind of looks like what we today would call sligh… (View Post)

I agree @Realone After staring at the images for 2 days, and combined with the letter Roger found showing the link, I have little, if any, doubt the Smith/Chapman Plated coin is today's PCGS PR6… (View Post)

I took the picture in that article vs a similar section of the Chapman Plate. Still leaning towards it being that particular coin. Find enough pictures and maybe some day they can pedigree it back to… (View Post)

You can't even really see the O on the Chapman plate photos. Even the images taken in the last handful of years don't present the exact same. This is the Chapman photo and a Coin World/Lege… (View Post)