BustHalfBrian ✭✭✭✭

I put this at VF25, at best. The grade is so far off that it makes me think this could be a mechanical error. Am I missing something? PS: I do not own this coin; it recently sold on eBay. (View Post)

That price isn't too surprising. Why do you believe it "makes no sense at all" that it sold for $19.2k? CDN bid in AU50 is $22,800, and that coin appears to have AU+ detail. (View Post)

Great coin! It's almost certainly undergraded, but I tend to prefer a 63 in a "rattler" over a 64 in a new-generation holder. Thanks for sharing. (View Post)

It happens. It depends on the series, denomination, composition etc since NGC is more conservative than PCGS in some categories, and more lenient in others. A few years ago, I had a raw 90-CC dollar … (View Post)

FWIW, I was thinking 62 shot 63. I went with 63 because the strike is excellent for an O mint, and thought it deserved a grade bump for that. But, I think the reason for 61 by PCGS is subdued luster … (View Post)