Secret Santa 2015 -Last Call--Bonus SS !!

flatfoot816 · November 20, 2015 10:58AM

Greetings and Happy Turkey Day--if there is anyone else thinking about getting n please do so by tonite--9 PM. This is really going to be a nice SS year.

As an added bonus a true Secret Santa will be sending out 3 SS gifts to random participants regardless of category--though the gift will be in the +$100 category. So sign up boyz!

Groupings

2) Gifts of $40 - $100

3) Over $100

a new thread will be started tomorrow morning on when to ship etc...

Secret Santas 2015

$100 +

1. flatfoot816

2. galaxy27 PM on info Recv'd

3. yankeesman PM on info Recv'd

4. maddux69 PM on info Recv'd

5. dragnet PM on info Recv'd

6. belz PM on info Recv'd

7. pjb103183 PM on info Recv'd

8. Vintagefun PM on info Recv'd

9. curch PM on info Recv'd

10. BeRoyalKC PM on info Recv'd

11. Slum22 PM on info Recv'd

12. Sabrgeek

13. Cpettimind PM on info Recv'd

14. 1980scollector PM on info Recv'd

15. Hammerfan44 PM on info Received

16. NJ80sBBC PM on info Recv'd

17. JFKHeat PM on info Recv'd

18. Orioles Pm Recv'd

$40-$100

1. EASports Pm on info Recv'd

2. shu4040

3. Begsu1013 PM on info REcv'd

4. Estil PM on info Recv'd

5. DB*****ette PM on info Recv'd

6. That Guy PM Recv'd

galaxy27 · November 20, 2015 11:21AM

Definitely in if this goes down ($100+)

BeRoyalKC · November 20, 2015 11:23AM

I'm in. $40-$100 range. I will take requests in what the gifted likes / collects.

seebelow · November 20, 2015 11:25AM

Id like to...this could be great....but its my first time so what were the common problems in the past? Like, obv, don't send 50 $2 cards to clean out your collection, how do you match preferences or just wing it?

thanks for being the administrator!!!

newbie

NJ80sBBC · November 20, 2015 12:30PM

Seebelow nailed my questions (concerns). This forums has been so incredibly valuable to me I definitely want to give back in a material way.

curch · November 20, 2015 12:43PM

I'm in!

yankeesman · November 20, 2015 2:00PM

I'm in for the $100 plus if we get off the ground.

maddux69 · November 20, 2015 2:36PM

I'm in for 100+ as well. If need be Manny, I can help you with elf duties!

MULLINS5 · November 20, 2015 3:50PM

Good to pair people up with what they collect.

Dragnet · November 20, 2015 3:58PM

Sounds like a great idea. Count me in as well (Over $100)!

belz · November 20, 2015 9:01PM

I too am a newbie and would love to participate...put me down for over 100 category..thx for organizing.

flatfoot816 · November 20, 2015 9:50PM

good morning everyone. Good start to the thread. Let's get more people involved. Most common problem has been people who are relatively new sending garbage out and getting filet in return. As stated it's more about giving but no one ever likes to get hosed. Happy to see the over $100 category getting some love

pjb103183 · November 21, 2015 2:08AM

ive participated for the past 2 years and it has been really fun...count me in(100+)

flatfoot816 · November 21, 2015 4:36AM

bump for list

vintagefun · November 21, 2015 5:13AM

I'll go 100+

shu4040 · November 21, 2015 5:14AM

Thanks for organizing.

Just as a counterpoint the different price levels feels a little icky this year. Yes inevitably some people can afford more than others but the splitting of the board into different levels doesn't feel like get right holiday spirit. I'm in though. Deciding where I'll go.

seebelow · November 21, 2015 7:21AM

hi flatfoot, i realize by this tues is limiting...and Thanksgiving is here etc...perhaps move the deadline to the following tues/weds in order to get more participants? IDK.

Also, will there be a list of what people would like in general? Since currently the participants looks limited id hate to not have something they would not like and just send them what would appear random. Albeit, quality. Ex....100 bucks worth of Wacky Packages to what really would be the wrong person..

and thanks again..wonderful gesture.

maddux69 · November 21, 2015 7:39AM

I will start it out and let my collecting focus be known: Greg Maddux- looking to add more to my basic set as well as oddball items. Hank Aaron signed Topps cards- currently have 54, 55, 56, 57 and 76. Been focusing on Mantle as of late- just snagged the big one

Thanks for putting this together Manny!

flatfoot816 · November 21, 2015 7:51AM

Originally posted by: shu4040

Thanks for organizing.

Just as a counterpoint the different price levels feels a little icky this year. Yes inevitably some people can afford more than others but the splitting of the board into different levels doesn't feel like get right holiday spirit. I'm in though. Deciding where I'll go.

I understand we have never done it this way before--but I think the response thus far to it has been positive. Not trying to split the board and don't think it will. Hope you're in!

MULLINS5 · November 21, 2015 10:05AM

Originally posted by: shu4040
Thanks for organizing.

Just as a counterpoint the different price levels feels a little icky this year. Yes inevitably some people can afford more than others but the splitting of the board into different levels doesn't feel like get right holiday spirit. I'm in though. Deciding where I'll go.

+1 to all of the above.

Maybe since the $100+ is popular we can split it up two ways? One group for $100+ and everyone else at a minimum of $20 (or another low amount)? More participants this way and those looking to increase their chances of not receiving "bad" gifts can signup for the larger tier. I am honestly happy with whatever my Secret Santa sends and will probably signup for the lower amount and end up sending more anyways.

edit to add: I also think that whichever group people go with, their name shouldn't be displayed for all to see. If someone wants to go in the $100+ level they should PM the OP and the OP should match those people up behind closed doors. Just a suggestion.

belz · November 21, 2015 10:15AM

Totally cool...can't wait to give something great. My interests are pretty simple. I like to open packs/boxes where there's a chance at something great...I also collect hof auto modern cards...I also have a small collection of 80s PSA rookie cards of cool dudes like bo, Ripken, bonds, Clemens, McGwire etc. Of course anything mantle is always fun..this will be fun to see what everyone gets.

BeRoyalKC · November 21, 2015 12:45PM

You can bump me into the $100 slot.

slum22 · November 21, 2015 1:42PM

I am in. PM sent. Thanks for setting this up Manny.

flatfoot816 · November 21, 2015 10:50PM

Originally posted by: MULLINS5

Maybe since the $100+ is popular we can split it up two ways? One group for $100+ and everyone else at a minimum of $20 (or another low amount)? More participants this way and those looking to increase their chances of not receiving "bad" gifts can signup for the larger tier. I am honestly happy with whatever my Secret Santa sends and will probably signup for the lower amount and end up sending more anyways.

edit to add: I also think that whichever group people go with, their name shouldn't be displayed for all to see. If someone wants to go in the $100+ level they should PM the OP and the OP should match those people up behind closed doors. Just a suggestion.

I think that $40 is a pretty reasonable amount for 95% of the people on the CU boards. As for showing the names-- it gives a person a good chance to see who they may want to get connected with. I've already received 3 PMs form members who want to send to certain people in the $100+ club.

MULLINS5 · November 21, 2015 11:29PM

Originally posted by: flatfoot816

Originally posted by: MULLINS5

Maybe since the $100+ is popular we can split it up two ways? One group for $100+ and everyone else at a minimum of $20 (or another low amount)? More participants this way and those looking to increase their chances of not receiving "bad" gifts can signup for the larger tier. I am honestly happy with whatever my Secret Santa sends and will probably signup for the lower amount and end up sending more anyways.

edit to add: I also think that whichever group people go with, their name shouldn't be displayed for all to see. If someone wants to go in the $100+ level they should PM the OP and the OP should match those people up behind closed doors. Just a suggestion.

I think that $40 is a pretty reasonable amount for 95% of the people on the CU boards. As for showing the names-- it gives a person a good chance to see who they may want to get connected with. I've already received 3 PMs form members who want to send to certain people in the $100+ club.

I see. It's definitely different than previous years. I will signup but still thinking about which price group. Thanks for putting this together!

EAsports · November 22, 2015 2:38AM

I'm in for $40 - 100.

shu4040 · November 22, 2015 4:11AM

I'm in for th 40/100. Thanks

Sabrgeek · November 22, 2015 4:51AM

In at whatever level is needed

Rich

vintagefun · November 22, 2015 5:44AM

To seebelow and nj80s, I see you have some open questions...

I typically plan to spend at least the minimum on something the person wants. There may be times when you luck out and have a good match...but I always go in expecting to spend the minimum. Once I feel they'll be relatively happy, that's when I look at some of the items I have to doll it up a bit, and put my own influence on the minority (bonus) part of the gift.

I hope to see you guys join.

Also, it'd be great to have partners identified by Wednesday, so we can take advantage of Black Friday and/or the eBay Bucks I'm expecting this week.

Looking forward to another great CU SS.

Thanks Manny!

Estil · November 22, 2015 6:17AM

What the heck, I'll go ahead and through my hat in the ring!

$40-$99 range.

cpettimd · November 22, 2015 7:28AM

Hook me up in the $100 plus group

skrezyna23 · November 22, 2015 12:47PM

If someone is interested in Korean baseball cards, in exchange for Mattingly material, feel free to respond here and I'll join the $40-$100 group.

begsu1013 · November 22, 2015 2:17PM

i'd like to get creative in the $40/$100 club.

flatfoot816 · November 22, 2015 9:29PM

good morning gents--

list updated for all participants thru Monday morning. I will make the pairings no later than Weds morning so you can take advantage of Black Friday, eBay bucks etc.

If you have not sent me your wish list and other info please do. Sent a PM out to all who have signed up.

flatfoot816 · November 22, 2015 9:40PM

Also--if you have a registry set that you are looking for additions--please identify your registry set so I can inform your SS

1980scollector · November 22, 2015 11:34PM

100+

Manny, thanks for doing this. It has always been fun.

Only suggestion- I would make is each participant should upload pictures of what they receive. My favorite part of it is to see what others got.

Estil · November 23, 2015 9:51AM

Hee hee, don't forget to mark "Does not suck" for those who sent their presents!

flatfoot816 · November 24, 2015 4:18AM

ttt

DanBessette · November 24, 2015 5:19AM

Pm sent

curch · November 24, 2015 5:38AM

Originally posted by: 1980scollector
100+

Manny, thanks for doing this. It has always been fun.

Only suggestion- I would make is each participant should upload pictures of what they receive. My favorite part of it is to see what others got.

I agree!

DanBessette · November 24, 2015 7:29AM

I'm in, 40-100.

1980scollector · November 24, 2015 1:22PM

Originally posted by: MULLINS5

Originally posted by: flatfoot816

Originally posted by: MULLINS5

Maybe since the $100+ is popular we can split it up two ways? One group for $100+ and everyone else at a minimum of $20 (or another low amount)? More participants this way and those looking to increase their chances of not receiving "bad" gifts can signup for the larger tier. I am honestly happy with whatever my Secret Santa sends and will probably signup for the lower amount and end up sending more anyways.

edit to add: I also think that whichever group people go with, their name shouldn't be displayed for all to see. If someone wants to go in the $100+ level they should PM the OP and the OP should match those people up behind closed doors. Just a suggestion.

I think that $40 is a pretty reasonable amount for 95% of the people on the CU boards. As for showing the names-- it gives a person a good chance to see who they may want to get connected with. I've already received 3 PMs form members who want to send to certain people in the $100+ club.

I see. It's definitely different than previous years. I will signup but still thinking about which price group. Thanks for putting this together!

Still waiting on your particaption with all the suggestions.

NJ80sBBC · November 25, 2015 12:41AM

Hi Manny, count me in for $100+ and thank you for organizing!

flatfoot816 · November 25, 2015 10:57PM

Happy Turkey Day!

bumpage for new Bonus Secret Santa!!

need to hear from Sabregeek--shu4040--on your info.

Thanks!

1980scollector · November 25, 2015 11:15PM

This is always my favorite thread of the year. However, for somebody to be sending out Extra SS gifts is pretty cool stuff. It just reminds you we have special people here. Whoever receives them post the items. That has always been my favorite part of it. Have a Happy Thanksgiving.

jfkheat · November 26, 2015 12:30AM

I have watched this SS for the last few years but never joined in. Add me to the $100 plus list.

James

NJ80sBBC · November 26, 2015 3:35AM

Stumbled on the SS thread last year before I joined and thought "how awesome is this place?" Very psyched to be a small part of it all. And just incredibly cool that someone is playing extra SS with the bonus gifts.

Happy Thanksgiving everyone!

NJ80sBBC · November 26, 2015 3:38AM

Originally posted by: vintagefun

To seebelow and nj80s, I see you have some open questions...

I typically plan to spend at least the minimum on something the person wants. There may be times when you luck out and have a good match...but I always go in expecting to spend the minimum. Once I feel they'll be relatively happy, that's when I look at some of the items I have to doll it up a bit, and put my own influence on the minority (bonus) part of the gift.

I hope to see you guys join.

Also, it'd be great to have partners identified by Wednesday, so we can take advantage of Black Friday and/or the eBay Bucks I'm expecting this week.

Looking forward to another great CU SS.

Thanks Manny!

Thank you for the insight! Now you got me thinking about what unopened I will add from my PC to top off the gift.

lilmule · November 26, 2015 3:53AM

Happy Thanksgiving everyone.

Flatfoot PM sent.

Orioles · November 26, 2015 8:13AM

i'm in for $100+ category. PM sent

Dboneesq · November 26, 2015 11:48AM

Although I will not be participating this year, I can't wait to see all the gifts that you guys give and receive. This is definitely one of my favorite threads of the year. I have to say that I was amazed at the generosity of my SS in the past years.

Secret Santa 2015 -Last Call--Bonus SS !!

Comments