ICG holder Bust half - Grade posted

coin22lover

Why don't we have a good old fashioned guess the grade thread.






.

Moldnut

Where's the coin

BTW, Im in at EF45

coin22lover

<< <i>Where's the coin >>



In my safe

noow

That's a "Knock-Out" coin

Kove

I voted AU53

jayPem

Not the easiest pics to grade from...can't tell if there is wear or just a mushy strike on the obverse.
From one perspective it looks VF, from another AU.

I'm guessing 50.

LindeDad

If all I have to go on is the shown image I'll grade it Pass.

DIMEMAN

looks 35-40 net to me.

Constantine

I may come in low at 35

cmerlo1

45

Dave99B

50

lkeigwin

Is this a guess the ICG grade? Or guess how it ends up at PCGS?

I'm in at 35 by our hosts, 45 in its current holder.
Lance.

ChangeInHistory

Their grade 40, my grade 35

sparky64

I went with 53.

mozin

PCGS 40

coin22lover

Thanks for the guesses - grade posted. Did anyone notice the variety?

mozin

I guessed the grade correctly, now you want to know which special variety it is? I see it is as not a special variety, but one never knows. Aren't Busties fun? Go to CoinZip, if you want to know more. All the marriages are shown there. Have fun!

coin22lover

<< <i>I guessed the grade correctly, now you want to know which special variety it is? I see it is as not a special variety, but one never knows. Aren't Busties fun? Go to CoinZip, if you want to know more. All the marriages are shown there. Have fun! >>



I believe it's the 1836 / 1336

grote15

Accurately graded, imo, maybe even a bit conservatively so. I thought you had crossed it to PCGS and guessed XF45.

coin22lover

<< <i>Accurately graded, imo, maybe even a bit conservatively so. I thought you had crossed it to PCGS and guessed XF45. >>




It'll most definitely be going with my next submission. It has plenty of luster and I think it's under graded.

Meltdown

I like the coin, but think it's accurately graded as a 40

Treashunt

40

jayPem

<< <i>

<< <i>I guessed the grade correctly, now you want to know which special variety it is? I see it is as not a special variety, but one never knows. Aren't Busties fun? Go to CoinZip, if you want to know more. All the marriages are shown there. Have fun! >>



I believe it's the 1836 / 1336 >>



Thats what it looks like...check 107 too, but you should be able to see the remnant 3 with a loupe, shouldn't you ?
if it is as lusterous as it looks in your pics, I'll stand by my guess of 50....maybe 45 at pcgs

mozin

The 1836/1336, in XF40, should have the remnants of the lower 3 knob end visible inside the lower loop of the 8. It may show with the coin in hand, but I certainly do not see it in the picture. Take a look at one of my 1836/1336.

coinkat

It looks to be a decent coin- 40-45 seems reasonable.

Lets not get trapped into using the holder to grade the coin- learn to recognize the striking charateristics of the date and draw reasonable conclusions

coin22lover

<< <i>The 1836/1336, in XF40, should have the remnants of the lower 3 knob end visible inside the lower loop of the 8. It may show with the coin in hand, but I certainly do not see it in the picture. Take a look at one of my 1836/1336.


>>




Thanks, I knew I was missing something. I took a look under my loupe and that small remnant in the lower left side of the loop of the 8 is definitely there, so variety confirmed

Now, what's an 1836/1336 worth in this grade?

johnny9434

<< <i>

<< <i>Where's the coin >>



In my safe >>

behind jesus.

BillJones

The piece seems to have some luster on the reverse, but the obverse is too scruffy to make AU. I think ICG pretty much got it right although one could make a convincing argument for calling it a VF-35. The old time collectors used to say if you were within 5 points on a circulated grade, you were pretty much in agreement.