Ty Cobb & Payton Manning Autographs - Real or Fake? Opinions Requested Please

Meatloaf

I found a small autographed cut (not much larger than 2" x 3") if Ty Cobb and a 5 x 7 auto photo of Payton Manning (see pictures below). I have not purchased these items and I am about to submit both it for a QO. Before I drop the $10, I wanted to get advice on the forums of likely authenticity. Does anyone out there collect Cobb or Manning signed memorabilia? Are these autos consistent with their signatures? What do you think of the likely authenticity? Thank you for your opinions and advice. Meatloaf

EagleEyeKid

Manning looks good. Don't know anything about Cobb.

Sean1125

Manninh 100% authentic no comment on cobb

BobbyVCP

Cobb does not look right to me

theczar

If it is says p"A"yton it is definitely a fake.

Sean1125

<< <i>If it is says p"A"yton it is definitely a fake. >>



I believe we know it says "Peyton" to be giving an opinion of "Authentic.

Just my two cents.

Meatloaf

<< <i>If it is says p"A"yton it is definitely a fake. >>



Sighhhh....failure on my part. Meatloaf

TmbrWolf22

meatloaf.....I snickered a little at your attempt at humor......does that count?....LOL. Don't sweat it, we all got it.

Edited to add....ooops...wrong person LOL.

TmbrWolf22

Heres an example for ya....although I've seen better sigs from him.

Meatloaf

<< <i>meatloaf.....I snickered a little at your attempt at humor......does that count?....LOL. Don't sweat it, we all got it.

Edited to add....ooops...wrong person LOL. >>



Thanks for the encouragement and the sample auto card / picture. Meatloaf