Membership Renewal Grades

tombo

What is the general opinion on whether or not PSA grading on free vouchers is consistent with their grading of other cards? Here are my recent renewal results: Parkhurst exceeded my expectations and the Graziano must have a slight wrinkle.

PSA Order Status for Submission # 4588947


LINE # CERT # CARD CARD CO. CARD # CARD NAME VARIETY GRADE
1 07226767 1952 PARKHURST 75 JOE KLUKAY N/A 8
2 07226768 1947 D. CUMMINGS & SON 12 ROCKY GRAZIANO FAMOUS FIGHTERS 5
3 07226769 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 26 JACK DEMPSEY FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
4 07226770 1951 TOPPS RINGSIDE 32 ROCKY MARCIANO N/A 4
5 07226771 1971 BARRATT & CO. LTD 24 CASSIUS CLAY FAMOUS SPORTSMEN 8
6 07226772 1971 BARRATT & CO. LTD 24 CASSIUS CLAY FAMOUS SPORTSMEN 8

Date Received: 08/22/2007
Date of Grades Posted: 08/31/2007
Date Shipped: No Date Specified

HeritageAddict

I don't know, my first sub with the 12 membership vouchers was by far the best I have had and the funny thing is I didn't look over the cards very good at all and it yielded 5-10's, 5-9's, 2-8's. Since then I have used a 10x loupe and been much more selective and my grades have been far worse. So either I need to go back to just using my naked eye or they used the membership vouchers to sucker me in.