Buffalo fans. Will this one attribute?
Top one is a 1916-D 3-1/2 legger in an AU 58 PCGS holder, (took 2 submissions) Second one is a recent pickup.I t's going to be a hard sell for PCGS to tell me the second one shouldn't get the designation too. Everybody else is free to weigh in. Also looks to be a nicer coin, AU-59 (if it existed?)